Sukkah 27: The Hotel California of Sukkahs
Talking Talmud - Een podcast door Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
Categorieën:
How many meals must be eaten in the sukkah? The mishnah says: 14, day and night, each day. But that's disputed - between a meal a day and no set amount.... Which leads to a deeper dive into R. Eliezer's approach. Including not moving from one sukkah to another. What if you missed a meal? Can you make it up on Shemini Atzeret? Plus, a story about King Agrippas's steward, and how he only eats one meal per day. The claim is that one should push oneself to honor Hashem with the 14 meals. Plus, a man with 2 wives, and therefore 2 sukkot. Which seems to counter R. Eliezer's opinion, effectively... And yet he seems quite determined. But practically, what if you've hit that quota of required meals - do the extra need to be in the sukkah? The Gemara is not clear, though it seems obvious to us. Also, can you build a sukkah on chol hamoed? In a new place? In the same place, if the wind knocked it down? Which leads to analysis of R. Eliezer's approach vs. Rabbanan, and how they all use the biblical text to support, or as impetus, for the different views. Plus, how does the requirement for sukkah compare to that of lulav?
